The purpose of this project was to prioritize a
portfolio of over 8,000 properties for suitability to locate cellular transmission towers.
To assure the objectivity and defensibility of the prioritization, we developed an
internally consistent mathematical model using techniques of multi-attribute decision
theory (Keeney, Ralph L. and Howard Raiffa, Decisions With Multiple Objectives.
Cambridge University Press, 1993). The model was implemented in ArcView 3.0 software using
commercially available digital maps of New Jersey.
We identified four classes of attributes relevant to site
prioritization: environmental, regulatory, technical, and commercial. The environmental
attributes describe esthetic and regulatory restrictions on site use. The regulatory
attributes describe specific restrictions related to airport proximity and other zones.
The technical attributes include the existence of tall buildings suitable for siting
towers, land cover, and elevation. The commercial attributes include population density
and traffic density along major highway and rail corridors.
Through guided questioning of expert engineers and consultants, we
developed suitable methods to measure the attributes and mathematical score functions to
combine them into numbers for site prioritization. Many attribute measurements require
spatial analysis for calculation. For example, commercial suitability depends heavily on
potential use of a hypothetical tower site. Use will depend on the total amount of highway
"visible" from the site, on the traffic along the highway, on the population
"visible" from the site, and on the demographics of that population. Thus, in
addition to visibility calculations, one must also compute these traffic and demographic
coverage factors. The GIS made these calculations possible and efficient.
Quantitative Decisions
Merion, Pennsylvania
info@quantdec.com